Nagad vs bKash: Which Steals More via Hidden Charges?
Introduction
In Bangladesh, bKash and Nagad dominate the mobile financial services (MFS) industry, providing millions of users with easy access to digital transactions. However, one of the biggest concerns for customers is the hidden charges these platforms impose on transactions, cash-outs, and service fees. While both claim to offer affordable services, users often find themselves paying more than expected.
This article breaks down the hidden costs of bKash and Nagad, compares their charges, and determines which platform takes more from your wallet.
Image credit: https://www.prnewswire.com/apac/news-releases/nagad-ignites-sdgs-thru-digital-financial-inclusion-in-bangladesh-301876406.html
Understanding Hidden Charges in Mobile Financial Services
Before diving into specific comparisons, it’s crucial to understand what hidden charges mean in mobile financial services. These charges may not always be clearly disclosed to users and often include:
- Cash-out fees (withdrawal charges)
- Send money fees (person-to-person transfers)
- Service charges (bill payments, merchant transactions)
- Dormancy fees (charges on inactive accounts)
- Tax and VAT deductions (additional government-imposed fees)
While the Bangladesh Bank regulates financial services, MFS providers still impose fees that often go unnoticed until after a transaction is completed.
bKash: The King of Hidden Fees?
bKash, being the pioneer of mobile financial services in Bangladesh, has the largest user base. However, it has often been criticized for its high transaction charges.
1. Cash-Out Charges
- bKash charges 1.85% per withdrawal.
- Example: If you withdraw ৳1,000, you pay ৳18.50 in fees.
- Hidden aspect: Many users assume they will receive the full amount when withdrawing from agents, but the fee is deducted automatically.
2. Send Money Fees
- Sending money to non-merchant accounts incurs a 1.5% fee.
- Example: Sending ৳1,000 to a friend costs ৳15 extra.
- Merchant payments are fee-free, but only if done via a merchant QR code.
3. ATM Withdrawals
- Customers using bKash ATM withdrawals at banks like Brac Bank face an additional charge of 1.5%.
4. Dormancy Charges
- Inactive bKash accounts may lose balance over time due to service fees, which are not explicitly mentioned during account setup.
While bKash remains a trusted MFS provider, its fee structure is one of the highest in the market, making it expensive for frequent transactions.
Nagad: A Better Alternative or Just Another Fee Trap?
Nagad, a relatively newer player backed by the Bangladesh Post Office, markets itself as a low-cost alternative to bKash. However, it also has hidden charges that may surprise users.
1. Cash-Out Charges
- Nagad claims to offer a lower cash-out fee of 1.49%.
- Example: Withdrawing ৳1,000 costs ৳14.90, which is cheaper than bKash.
- Hidden aspect: Only certain “preferred agents” offer this lower rate; many agents charge higher.
2. Send Money Fees
- Nagad allows free P2P transfers for most transactions, which is a major advantage over bKash.
- However, for certain transfers exceeding limits, a 1% charge applies.
3. ATM Withdrawals
- Nagad offers free ATM withdrawals for premium users but charges 1% for standard users.
4. VAT & Additional Fees
- Some transactions are subject to 15% VAT on service charges, which is not always clearly disclosed.
While Nagad generally offers lower fees than bKash, its inconsistent agent pricing model and hidden VAT charges can still catch users off guard.
Which MFS Provider Steals More Money?
To determine which platform extracts more money from users via hidden charges, let’s compare them side by side.
| Service | bKash | Nagad |
| Cash-Out Fee | 1.85% | 1.49% (selected agents) |
| Send Money Fee | 1.5% | Free (some limits apply) |
| ATM Withdrawal Fee | 1.5% | 1% (or free for premium users) |
| Dormancy Charges | Yes | No |
| Hidden VAT | Applied | Applied (not clearly disclosed) |
Final Verdict
- bKash takes more from users overall, due to higher transaction fees and dormancy charges.
- Nagad appears cheaper but has inconsistent agent fees and hidden VAT charges.
- For casual users, Nagad is a better option due to its lower cash-out and free send-money service.
- For business users, bKash remains reliable but comes at a higher cost.
How to Avoid Hidden Fees in Mobile Financial Services
If you want to reduce unnecessary charges, follow these tips:
- Use merchant QR codes for bKash payments to avoid unnecessary transaction fees.
- Withdraw from official bank ATMs instead of agents for better rates.
- Keep an eye on VAT deductions by checking transaction summaries.
- Ask agents about cash-out rates before proceeding with withdrawals.
- Consider using alternative digital wallets that offer lower fees.
Conclusion
Both bKash and Nagad have their own hidden charges, but bKash generally takes more money through higher transaction fees, ATM withdrawal costs, and dormancy charges. Nagad, while cheaper on paper, also has hidden VAT deductions and agent-dependent pricing.
For users looking to save money, understanding fee structures and transaction policies is crucial. Being aware of these hidden costs can help users choose the right provider and avoid unnecessary expenses.
Disclaimer
The information provided in this article is based on publicly available data and official sources. Service charges and policies may change over time. Readers should verify fees from official websites or customer service before making financial decisions. This article does not provide financial or legal advice.
Ethan
|
2025.03.27
